In-House vs Agency: Who Should Manage Your Digital Marketing?

Digital marketing is the lifeblood of modern businesses. Effective digital marketing can significantly boost your brand visibility, customer engagement, and sales, whether you're a local mom-and-pop shop or a multinational corporation.

However, the question that often arises is: Should you keep your digital marketing in-house, or should you enlist the expertise of a digital marketing agency? As someone who's been a seasoned marketer and now an agency owner, I'll share some insights that might help you make an informed decision.

Understanding In-House Digital Marketing

When discussing in-house digital marketing, we refer to a dedicated team within your company handling your digital marketing efforts. This team is part of your company, living and breathing your brand daily.

Moreover, an in-house digital marketing team offers a distinctive advantage of direct communication and seamless integration with your brand's vision and objectives. They know your business inside and out, have a clear understanding of your brand's voice, and are readily available to align with the dynamic needs of your company. Their intimate knowledge of the brand and its history allows them to pivot quickly, adapt marketing strategies to internal changes, and respond to crises in real time.

The Upsides of In-House Digital Marketing

• Control and Flexibility: When I was a digital marketer in a company, one of our most significant advantages was control and flexibility. We could make quick decisions, implement changes rapidly, and react to market trends instantly.
• Company Culture and Product Knowledge: As employees, we were deeply ingrained in the company's culture and understood the product inside out. This deep-rooted knowledge and connection are often reflected in our marketing campaigns.
• Cost Considerations: In-house teams can also be more cost-effective in the long run, especially if you have a steady, high volume of work.

The Downsides of In-House Digital Marketing

• Limited Expertise and Resources: Despite our best efforts, we often found ourselves limited by our in-house expertise and resources. For example, we needed to gain the skills to run an extensive PPC campaign or the creative resources to produce high-quality video content.
• Risk of Stagnation: There were also times when our ideas seemed to stagnate, recycling old concepts without bringing anything new to the table.
• High Turnover Rates: High turnover rates, a common issue in the marketing field, can affect the consistency and effectiveness of marketing efforts.

Understanding Agency Digital Marketing

Now, let's switch hats. As an agency owner, hiring an agency to manage your digital marketing means enlisting a team of external experts who specialize in different areas of digital marketing.

Bringing in an agency brings diversity to the table - they come with a wealth of experiences and insights from working with various industries and markets. This broad perspective can be invaluable in recognizing unique opportunities and creative strategies that might otherwise be missed. They have seen what works and what doesn’t across various clients and can apply these insights to your business. Furthermore, they are adept at staying on top of digital marketing trends, ensuring that your business capitalizes on the latest tactics and platforms.

Secondly, digital marketing agencies have the resources to dive deep into analytics, track KPIs, and use sophisticated tools that may be cost-prohibitive for many businesses. They invest in the latest technology and software to ensure they deliver the best results for their clients. Agencies provide detailed reports, measure ROI effectively, and adjust strategies based on data-driven insights, offering transparency and assurance that your investment is yielding results. These factors combined provide a compelling case for the benefits an external agency can bring to your digital marketing efforts.

Choosing an agency can often be more cost-effective than maintaining an in-house team. With an agency, you can access a team of experts who have invested in the latest technology and professional development without the overhead of salaries, benefits, and ongoing training.

Additionally, an agency provides continuity. Even if your contact at the agency leaves, there is a team behind them to continue the work, reducing the risk of disruption to your marketing activities. Opting for an agency means you get high-quality, uninterrupted service that caters to your specific needs, often at a fraction of the cost of an in-house team.

The Benefits of Agency Digital Marketing

• Access to a Wide Range of Expertise and Tools: At our agency, we have specialists in SEO, PPC, content marketing, social media, and more. Plus, we invest in the latest tools and software that many companies might need access to or afford on their own.
• Scalability: With an agency, businesses can scale their marketing efforts up or down depending on their needs and budget.
• Fresh Perspectives and Innovation: Agencies work with various clients across industries, often leading to creative cross-pollination. We bring new, innovative ideas to the table, which clients greatly appreciate.

The Drawbacks of Agency Digital Marketing

• Less Control and Slower Communication: Outsourcing your digital marketing may mean less direct control and slower communication times. As an agency, we always strive to communicate promptly, but we can't match the immediacy of an in-house team.
• Lack of Company-Specific Knowledge: While agencies can learn about your company and market, we might have a different intimate understanding than an in-house team.
• Cost Considerations: While an agency's services can often be customized to your budget, they can be expensive, especially for small businesses or startups.

Making the Decision

Should you go in-house or hire an agency? There's no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as the best choice depends on your circumstances.

Factors to Consider

• Business Size and Needs: A small business with limited needs might do well with an in-house team, while a large corporation with complex needs might benefit more from an agency's broad expertise.
• Budget: If budget is a concern, you might start with an in-house team and later engage an agency as your needs and finances grow.
• Long-Term Growth Plans: Your long-term growth strategy can also influence your decision. If rapid expansion is in the cards, an agency's scalability could be a significant advantage.

Balancing In-House and Agency Inputs

The most effective digital marketing strategies often come from a mix of in-house and agency inputs. This balance allows for deep brand understanding combined with fresh external perspectives.

Cost Comparison

The cost difference between hiring an in-house digital marketing specialist and outsourcing to an agency is quite remarkable. In the United States, the average salary for a digital marketing specialist is $64,105 annually. If we consider Canada, the average salary appears higher at CAD $74,362, but due to currency exchange rates (1 USD = 1.34 CAD, as of writing), the figure is actually comparable when converted to US dollars. In the United Kingdom, the average salary is £33,000. These costs reflect the salary of just one specialist, and they increase considerably when you add in benefits, software, and continuous training expenses.

Compare this to the average annual contract of a marketing agency, which is around $28,000. This cost covers an entire team of specialists who bring unique expertise to the table, and it includes all the necessary tools, technology, and ongoing training expenses. Thus, it's evident that partnering with a marketing agency can be a significantly more cost-effective approach for businesses aiming to expand their digital marketing efforts.

Quick Recap

Choosing between in-house and agency for your digital marketing needs is a significant decision that can impact your business's success. While both have pros and cons, the best choice depends on your unique needs, resources, and long-term goals. This article has provided you with some insights to make that decision easier. And remember, whether you choose to go in-house or hire an agency, the goal remains the same: to create compelling digital marketing strategies that propel your business forward.

Ready to propel your business to new heights with strategic digital marketing? Need help navigating the complex digital world. Reach out to Reputation Mart today! 

Our team of seasoned experts is ready to customize a digital marketing plan that aligns perfectly with your unique business needs. Call us now and take the first step towards unprecedented growth and success!

Contact Us